We need a Fact Checker for the Liberal Fact checkers. After the Paul Ryan speech someone set out to accuse Paul Ryan of lying with their dishonest supposed fact checking. I will take a look at four statements that were rated false.
The worst example so called fact checking was a fact check was claiming President Obama was not responsible for the credit downgrade. This is not surprising as the left and Obama refuse to be responsible for anything. The fact checkers argued that the downgrade happened because of Republicans in congress threatening to shutdown the government if Obama would not cut spending. This would be like believing your credit rating is hurt because your wife would not let you get another credit card and just max out the one you have. The truth is Obama wanted a clean debt ceiling increase which would be worse for our credit rating than the deal that was struck resulting in a downgrade. S&P said the downgrade "reflects our opinion that the fiscal consolidation plan that Congress and the administration recently agreed to falls short of what, in our view, would be necessary to stabilize the government's medium-term debt dynamics." (1) In short the deal did not cut enough in the medium term. Before this deal was struck Obama rejected an offer from the GOP basically caving to his desire for more revenues and instead moved the goalposts to ensure a larger conflict. He thought he would win politically if the government was shut down. While Obama wanted to do nothing, the GOP passed Cut Cap & Balance which would have avoided the downgrade. Clearly the downgrade is all on Obama and it demonstrates his inability to lead. We can rate this fact check as Pants on Fire wrong.
Then we have the statement about the Janesville GM plant. The statement was 100% correct. He quoted Obama. Paul Ryan did not say Obama was responsible for the closing of that plant. His point was it is an example false hope offered by Obama as he campaigned in 2008. Fact checkers focused on the fact that the plant closed in December 23, 2008 before Obama took office, which is irrelevant to the point. This false hope continued for years as there were rumors of a possible re-opening of the plant. This fact check is also completely false. (2)
Paul Ryan made a comment critical of the failed Stimulus. The supposed Fact checkers complained Paul Ryan helped some Wisconsin companies get stimulus money. This is again irrelevant information. Once the bill becomes law, Paul Ryan should try to help his constituents get what benefits they can from the law even if he disagreed with the law. I may disagree with a tax deduction, but I am still going to take it if I can. Again Paul Ryan was correct and the fact checkers had this wrong.
Paul Ryan was critical of Obama for rejecting the Simpson-Bowles commission recommendations. The fact checkers argued this was unfair because Paul Ryan voted against the plan. This ignores that Paul Ryan offered another plan that corrected the major failure of that plan, which was not dealing with healthcare the major driver of our debt. (2) Obama meanwhile has created budgets that ignore our major issues. Then after pressure from some in his own party he came out with a framework that falls way short of being a serious solution.(3) Fine, if you don’t like your own commission’s plan, but President Obama should have proposed a serious alternative, especially after Paul Ryan came out with his plan.
I guess my point is that we cannot trust any of these fact checking sites as they are not honest. We need to explore these issues on our own. Politicians often say things that are stretching the truth or outright lies. These items however are not examples of either. Each statement above was correct for the point Ryan was making.