patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Which Do You Prefer — Black Friday or Cyber Monday?

It's time to get your shop on, and rise of online shopping and Cyber Monday has given deal-hungry consumers some options.

 

With Thanksgiving occurring on the earliest possible day this year, the official holiday shopping season is as long as it can be.

For years, the Friday following Thanksgiving — Black Friday — was the unquestioned king of that season. But the furious growth of the Internet has spawned Cyber Monday, an online shopping frenzy that grew 22 percent from 2010 to $1.25 billion in sales in the United States.

It still pales in comparison to Black Friday, which last year generated $52.4 billion in sales, up from $45 billion in 2010.

Many shoppers enjoy the early rising, elbow-to-elbow aisles and energy of in-person shopping on Black Friday, and the game-planning that goes with it. Others would prefer to sit in their home or office and cross off gift lists with clicks of a mouse.

Which is your favorite? Vote in our unscientific poll, then jump into the comment stream to tell us about your holiday shopping habits and secrets.

And while you’re at it, check out holiday shopping hours for major area shopping malls:

  • Which do you prefer — Black Friday or Cyber Monday

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Black Friday
        2 (4%)
    • Cyber Monday
        9 (20%)
    • I do both!
        5 (11%)
    • I avoid it all.
        27 (62%)
    Total votes: 43
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Black Friday, Cyber Monday, Deals, and Holiday Shopping

Joel Kopischke

6:44 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

The story should also talk about Small Business Saturday. Locally owned small businesses keep more of the money in our community. Shop local! http://www.sba.gov/saturday

Reply
Comment_arrow

@-;-'---- Rose

12:42 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Yes, Joel...I learned this from my sister's husband many years ago when we all lived in Manitowoc where his parents owned the local Ace Hardware. Wherever he lived they always shopped local in later years. In Waukesha they shopped downtown first...always.

theresa graff

7:02 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

I second Joel's comment. And make a plea for Boycotting shopping before 7am on Friday. The employees, their families and families everywhere are missing out on the greatest holiday of the year - Thanksgiving, by cutting the holiday short to punch in for the next holiday. And we wonder what has happened to the American family. We're so distracted. we don't make time for each other.

Reply
Comment_arrow

alt ideas needed

8:17 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

make everyday a small business day

Comment_arrow

Craig

8:58 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Some employees may want to work Thanksgiving evening in exchange for Christmas Eve off. Or maybe they need the money and are happy to have a job, and the extra hours.
Not everyone relies on Obamabucks to pay their bills, and soon the banks won't accept 'that' money.

Justa Comment

7:12 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

I feel sorry for the employees of the stores who are so greedy they feel they need to be open on Thanksgiving, on top of Black Friday. If people would only stay at home with their families that day, maybe the stores won't repeat this next year.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bob McBride

7:35 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Stores aren't "greedy". They're in business to make money. If consumers weren't willing to line up at virtually any hour of the day for a chance to save 20% on a limited supply of something they don't need, stores definitely wouldn't be open at that hour because there are costs associated with being open.

This has become a sport and social event for some people. Not my cup of tea, but so what? It's now a part of the culture.

Comment_arrow

Daniel S.

12:34 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Bob is right, stores aren't greedy, stores are inanimate objects; CEO's and their underlings are Greedy. People line up, because the Greedy employ marketing gurus with psychological expertise that know how to get into peoples' heads. It's the same method the government uses through media and other events that happen daily to distract the majority from paying attention to the shenanigans taking place with OUR tax dollars.

Comment_arrow

Bob McBride

1:42 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Keep an eye open for the black helicopters, Daniel. They'll be after you now that you've exposed them.

Comment_arrow

Luke

12:15 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Daniel,

I think you've confused the DNC with CEO's.

Comment_arrow

Daniel S.

7:03 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

No confusion here Luke, it's just the way it is. Happy Thanks-Giving ; )

Burton Robertson

7:49 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Very disappointed in The Patch. With your emphasis on small communities and not one mention about Small Business Saturday ! Reconsidering my stance and support of the Patch ! Wondering which paper to buy!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bob McBride

8:16 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Burton, they usually run a separate article (generally more in depth than this) on "Small Business Saturday" a little closer to the actual date. Still got a few days left here.

Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Jim Price

10:41 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Burton, Patches across the country – 900 of them – have been participating for weeks in a joint Small Business Saturday campaign, with each Patch site publishing a minimum of two small business stories every week – many of us do more. Small business is at the heart of every community, and it is at the core of Patch to cover small, locally owned business day-to-day throughout the year. But in my own Wauwatosa, in Brookfield, Greendale and the North Shore communities surrounding Bayshore Mall, in Waukesha – most Patch places, really – large retailers also matter, very much. They provide jobs and tax revenues, and certainly I believe that in the case of Mayfair Mall also create very large and powerful magnets that draw people from throughout the region to Wauwatosa, to the benefit of many of our smaller, indepedent businesses as well.

Historically, Patch has favored small business in day-to-day, year-round coverage. During the holidays, we support them, too, and strongly, but not by ignoring large business interests. If you visit Wauwatosa Patch right now, you will find two related small business stories at the top of the page – above the Black Friday story.

Comment_arrow

Denise Konkol

1:17 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

I'd search 'small business Satuday' Burton...we've been posting information from local merchants. We are also not a paper that is purchased.

Vigilante

8:04 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

So more and more Americans fall for this silly notion of sleeping outside g=for the best deals. Well China bathes in our money. JHEEEEEZUS people how much crap do you still need in your home you self rightous. If you only new the store mark ups that are put on this stuff as it all comes over from China. Its to bad the greed of store owners have ruined the whole meaning of Thanksgiving, young people have no understanding of why we have this holiday, only thing they know is to shop. Besides haven't our public schools instilled in them how racist our founding fathers where!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Steve ®

11:40 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Most retail is 30% tops. With the internet the playing field is even more level. There are so many loss leaders done on bf. Consumer spending drives our success and employees millions.

Steve ®

11:37 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Cyber Monday was a fad and is dying out. I will not be offering any special deals this year. Last year we had such a rush on Black Friday very few orders were taken Monday, They already blew their wad

Black Friday is our single best sales day of the year.

Reply

Str8shooter

12:20 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

If the consumers didn't have the demand the businesses wouldn't open early so before blaming the businesses for having the employees work on a holiday, blame the consumers who are shopping on a holiday. I don't get into Black Friday shopping but the demand is there so any smart business will provide the supply. Family values have gone down but people have the right to do what they want and many family members do Black Friday together. Employees know that is a part of their job and can find another one if they don't like it.

Reply

Str8shooter

12:25 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

But to answer the question...I don't take advantage of Black Friday or cyber Monday. I have purchased items on the Internet but am cautious due to not being able to see the item before buying. At the same time, I personally refuse to stand in line for hours in the cold at 2am. Just not for me.

Reply
Comment_arrow

@-;-'---- Rose

12:57 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Str8...I surely don't either!!...but I read all the comments here and most are valid opinions. My sons work overtime [not in stores] every chance they get to keep up with their bills as they listened to me while growing up: "You'll find your best helping hand here [stretched out arm and wiggling fingers] at he end of your own arm."

Daniel S.

12:29 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Here here for the Boycott Idea for shopping on Thanksgiving Day, if we could only get everyone in the nation to not shop before even 6am Friday it would send a message to the retailers. We Are tired of your Greed invading into every last aspect of Family or Individual Life. The Rulers of these companies are sitting on some Island or in their Castle while their slaves work their fingers to the bone for scraps of food fit for a dog in some cases. They are not showing THANKS to those who fill their pockets with Gold & Diamonds, they need to be hit where it hurts. We should organize an ALL Weekend Boycott and Christmas Holiday boycott. Instead of buying all the junk they want us to, we should buy nothing but gift cards for people, stick them with all this merchandise they try to shove down our throats. Buy useful gift cards, like for grocery stores, or restaurants, public transportation. Let's show them the Power of The PEOPLE. Happy Thanksgiving ALL : )

Reply
Comment_arrow

Lex Parsimoniae

9:32 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

Really? You want the source of the greed? A most simplistic explanation can be found on the Wal-Mart episode of South Park (juvenile, I know, but it seems to fit in with your outlook).

Spoiler alert - when they wanted to learn the secret of the Wal-Mart success (the metaphor for your corporate greed), and broke into the safe to find it, they found only a mirror.

Stores keep opening earlier and earlier, because the sheep keep lining up earlier and earlier.

mau

1:08 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Get ready to max out your credit cards.

Cash, the gift that keeps on giving.

I'm wondering if these same shoppers would camp out all night to be 1st in line for a job. And once they ram through the door of the employment office, running each other over, then hit and shove each other to be assured of getting the prized job.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Craig

8:28 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Good point Mau. I bet they wait in lines for free cell phones or gas for Quest cards. But when there is a job to be had, they all claim they can't find one.
I wonder if it is because most jobs test to be sure applicants are drug free?

Comment_arrow

mau

8:48 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Can't pass the drug test, can't read or do simple math and can't even show on time for the interview. This eliminates a large portion of candidates. Some Milwaukee liberal pundits would like to see marijuana legalized as this would take care of the drug test failures. So what do you get, a stoned employee who still can't read or do simple math and doesn't show up for work.

Comment_arrow

Daniel S.

11:17 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Legalizing marijuana at the state level does not mean an employer cannot drug test you for usage. They drug test for alcohol use too and it's legal. The only thing legalization would change, is the number of arrests for possession, lighten court load, save taxpayer $$'s on incarceration and free up police to focus on other more criminal acts.

@-;-'---- Rose

1:16 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Oh sure...I can just see all the "die hards" letting the lines get longer and longer with all the "die-even-harders" while they sleep or visit with relatives. I'm usually an optimist but can't get on this bandwagon.

Reply

Denise Konkol

1:19 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

HATE the Thanksgiving Day opens, no matter how late into the evening. It can wait. And year after year, people are told that the best time to buy is the week leading into Christmas.

Reply

KKP

2:12 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

IMHO, Black Friday, and the now Thanksgiving shopping, should be done away with. It is totally unfair to the stores' employees, AND it is a danger to consumers. Also unfair tactics on the part of most of the stores who advertise a huge deal and have many two of that item, and 500 people line up outside and trample each other to get those two items. It's just stupid. And dangerous...and unfair. Get a grip, America....nothing is worth the danger or the sacrificed family time.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Steve ®

3:43 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

We should give the doctors and nurses off too. So unfair

Comment_arrow

Bob McBride

3:51 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

It's too bad people don't have a choice as to whether they participate or not. This year I'm going to try hiding under a stairway in the basement when they come sweeping through the neighborhood, rousting us from our sleep, loading us into the backs of panel trucks and hauling us off to stand in line for hours in the dark in front of some Walmart. I'd really rather not go.

Comment_arrow

Daniel S.

4:37 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

If we give medical personnel off, how about Law Enforcement & Fire Protection, Bus Drivers, Airline Personnel, Public Utility personnel . . . why don't we just shut down the whole country for the day?

Comment_arrow

MDS

4:57 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Steve, We do give doctors and nurses off on Thanksgiving. Try making a doctor or dentist appointment on Thanksgiving, or schedule some elective surgery at midnight on Friday. Sure, the emergency rooms are open, but regularly scheduled medical procedures are not.

Comment_arrow

Steve ®

8:47 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

You're reading waaaaaay too far into my comment. If broke my keg on Thursday an orthopedic Dr would show up to pop it pack in place. A nurse would be there for eye candy and the janitor to clean up the mess. How unfair.

Comment_arrow

MDS

9:45 pm on Monday, November 19, 2012

Steve, if you break open a keg on Thanksgiving, then you are celebrating differently then I do! ;>)

Comment_arrow

Craig

10:43 pm on Monday, November 19, 2012

Steve dropped a keg on his leg last Thanksgiving?
Time to change to the hard stuff, it is much lighter.

Comment_arrow

Steve ®

12:53 pm on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

ha, silly phone posting while in a deer stand.

Jack lives with Steve ®

KKP

3:47 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Health care is necessary. Shopping is not.

Reply
Comment_arrow

James R Hoffa

4:06 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

@KKP -

Hoffa agrees. But it makes you wonder how many people appear to have money for 24" spinner rims, cell phone plans, fancy kicks, bling, pay TV services, cruise vacations, booze, cigs, illegal narcotics, etc. and yet, don't seem to ever have a dime to spend on their own health care, and instead insist that the government provide it / subsidize it for them.

Funny how that works, isn't it?

Comment_arrow

KKP

4:10 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

There's no accounting for some peoples' priorities.

Comment_arrow

Str8shooter

8:29 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Hoffa completely agree except the part about cell plans. Many of the people you're referring to don't pay for cell plans either. Tax payers pay for their one or more cell plans and will soon also pay their healthcare.

Daniel S.

4:40 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

@ B McB "It's too bad people don't have a choice as to whether they participate or not. This year I'm going to try hiding under a stairway in the basement . . . I'd really rather not go." This was very good ; ) . . . sadly it is apparently True for millions of citizens.

Reply

MDS

4:53 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

For hundreds of years, up until the 1960's it was common to have laws called blue laws which prohibited stores from being open on Sundays, and I think on most holidays as well. Conservatives supported these laws as it supported Christian values. Now money is the holy grail and nothing it seems should get in the way of the pursuit of profit.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Steve ®

8:51 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

Still can't shop for a car on Sunday. Less laws restraining and limiting capitalism the better. Especially in a crap Obama economy.

Comment_arrow

Daniel S.

10:34 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

Depends what state you live in; whether you can shop for a car or not. Only 15 states do not allow sales on Sunday and the majority are in the midwest. There are also states that do not allow alcohol sale on Sunday or have shortened/restricted sales or hours of operation. These laws have roots going back to the 17th century (1610) . . . . with repeal of laws beginning in the early 1950's.

Comment_arrow

Craig

10:42 pm on Monday, November 19, 2012

Funny that you can buy a car on Saturday but not Sunday.
Actually, state law does allow car sales on Sunday.
ie: If the dealership is Jewish owned, and honors their holy day from sundown Friday to sundown Saturday by being closed- then they may be open Sunday.
As you may have noticed, none want to be the only dealer closed on Saturday.

Fred Jackson

5:45 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

I got sucked into this just once. Never again.

Reply

jbw

7:03 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

No, I don't participate in those things at all. I do sometimes buy things at deeper discounts after a holiday. If a business' goal is to maximize profit (i.e. get you to pay the highest premium on the most merchandise) then the consumer's goal is the opposite - so you generally ought to spend nothing when someone else most wants you to spend. Hey, that's just business.

I would consider buying from one of those sales if they were selling something I actually need. Really, how many TV's and DVD players do you need? I don't even have one. You won't see huge discounts on things with real practical value because those aren't insanely overpriced the rest of the year.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Steve ®

8:54 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

A lot shopping on bf are purchasing gifts.

C. Sanders

7:43 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

I prefer any any that Harley branded goods are 25% off at the dealer.

Reply

Robert B.

9:00 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

Why does every single article have turn into a political debate? Don't you guys ever get sick of injecting that into all aspects of life? Forget boycotting shopping, I'm all for boycotting political comments. You're not changing anybody's mind, guys. Keep it to yourself for once.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Justa Comment

10:00 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

I agree. Republicans have to make every single thing political, they blame Obama for everything, I'm sure he is also responsible for the weather.

Comment_arrow

CowDung

10:07 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

I guess you don't recall how GW Bush was blamed for the hurricanes and other severe weather events during his time in office. It isn't just the republicans...

Comment_arrow

Craig

10:20 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

Robert B. : Not to worry, in four years we all will be standing in lines for our Thanksgiving turkey. People will not be talking politics then, they will be talking about the good old days, when you could earn a paycheck to BUY food.
The only business that will be successful will be those who manufacture Quest cards.

Comment_arrow

Daniel S.

11:33 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

I believe if one were to pay attention to typical conversation taking place throughout the country, you'd discover very little communication about politics and how to correct the issues facing the nation. More people are talking about irrelevant issues; sports, drinking, sex, purchases they made, hairdo's and makeovers, celebrities . . . true reality has taken a backseat to reality nonsense.

Comment_arrow

KKP

3:12 pm on Monday, November 19, 2012

I absolutely agree, Robert, I was thinking the same thing. This was a simple question about SHOPPING for crying out loud....Why does everything have to morph into political and/or racial issues?? let's keep to the subject here, which is SHOPPING. Political banter can be taken to other, more appropriate forums.

carpediem

9:29 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

Robert, I agree! Green Neighbor Wauwatosa and GoGreen in the Village are holding a Green Your Holidays evening, promoting not only more sensible gift giving but also putting more importance on less stress, more time together, less waste, etc. We can all be more constructive and complain less!

Reply

carpediem

9:33 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

The above mentioned event will be next Tuesday evening from 6 to 8pm. We will also have some kids activities planned. Love to see all of you there. There will be no politics involved. Humans are welcome!

Reply

NObama 2012

6:33 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

What's long and black and smells really bad? The line in front of Wal Mart on Black Friday.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Daniel S.

7:06 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Of course the line is black, it's night time when they open. But once day breaks, it sheds a whole new light on things. Thankfully I won't be there then, nor on any other day of the year.

Comment_arrow

Satori

8:25 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

America, this is your GOP

Comment_arrow

The Anti-Alinsky

8:45 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Keith and Satori, you jumped on that generalization way too quickly. Last month there was a rash of car thefts in Shorewood. Does that mean all Shorewood residents are car theives?

Comment_arrow

Steve ®

12:56 pm on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

I thought they were all tax revenue thieves.

Comment_arrow

The Anti-Alinsky

9:13 pm on Wednesday, November 21, 2012

No Steve ®, they were stimulus car theives.

KKP

8:28 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

No it is not. It is a few misguided individuals. Your comment is like saying all black people are crooks or all white people are racist. Do not condemn all of us for the comments of the few - or you are no better than they are.

Reply

Leave a comment